From what moment does Raskolnikov’s repentance begin? Essay on the topic: confession and repentance of Raskolnikov (f

Essays

Literature

Dostoevsky

The work of the outstanding writer Dostoevsky “Crime and Punishment” shows how a person can withstand all moral unrest, and Raskolnikov had many dreams.

The final chapter is considered the main action in the work; in it, the schismatics confess to the crime. We see such events in the chapter of repentance. Raskolnikov was sure that people are divided into two types, some overcome themselves and go to rebellion, and the people around them will agree with poor living conditions. He wanted to prove this theory to himself, whether I am a trembling creature or a person who has the right. Therefore, he decided to kill the old woman. He thought that he could live without thinking about the consequences of the crime he committed. But in the end, he destroyed his life, and the constant feeling of guilt does not give him salvation. Sonya Marmeladova provides enormous support in his life. This girl became a lifeline for him.

Raskolnikov developed warm feelings for the girl. But tormented by the monstrous act, the guy decides to tell her all the adventures that happened to him. Once at Sonya’s, he talks about the crime, but it was clear from his face that he must answer for the crime committed. This gave Raskolnikov hope of getting rid of his torment. Sonya said that he must go to Sennaya Square and ask for forgiveness from the earth, because he committed a sin before her, and not before the people, by declaring murder. Once on the square, he experienced a new feeling; then he was sure that he had to answer for his crime. But due to internal doubts, he was unable to talk about past events. Suddenly he realized that all the thoughts he believed in meant nothing. They make no sense, and the guy ruined his life with such actions.

Near the office, the young man’s legs went numb, but he continued to walk, realizing the correctness of his action. Unexpectedly, he met Prokhor, who was leading this case. Raskolnikov was overcome by fear that he had guessed his involvement in the crime. Upon entering the office, he could not confess to the murder. Suddenly Raskolnikov saw Sonya, who was hiding in the yard. The guy thought that she would support him in any situation, so he went into the office and told about the crime. Such recognition meant the insignificant existence of his nature. In fact, repentance came to him during hard labor after a conversation with Sonya and an appeal to God. In a difficult life situation, his soul was saved by love and humanity.

Other topics: ← Interiors in the novel Crime and Punishment ↑ Dostoevsky Numbers in the novel Crime and Punishment →

When and why did the schismatics repent?

Life and work of Dostoevsky. Analysis of works. Characteristics of heroes

Does Raskolnikov repent of his crime?

The main character of the famous novel Crime and Punishment, Rodion Raskolnikov, commits a terrible crime - the murder of an old pawnbroker and her sister Lizaveta.

After reading the novel, readers inevitably have a question: does Raskolnikov repent of his crime? Dostoevsky himself does not give a direct answer to this question, but some conclusions can still be drawn from the epilogue of the novel.

This article provides an answer to the question: does Raskolnikov repent of his crime?

See:
All materials on “Crime and Punishment” All materials about Raskolnikov

Does Raskolnikov repent of his crime?

As you know, after committing a crime, Rodion Raskolnikov is sent to hard labor in Siberia. Sonya Marmeladova, the protagonist's girlfriend, follows him. While in hard labor, Sonya visits Raskolnikov and supports him in every possible way.

One day Sonya catches a cold and does not appear in prison for several days. Sonya's absence worries Raskolnikov. He finally understands how dear Sonya is to him. Thanks to this forced separation, a revolution occurs in Raskolnikov’s soul:

“The next day Sonya didn’t come, and the third day too; he noticed that he was waiting for her with anxiety; he learned from the prisoners that Sofya Semyonovna was ill, was lying at home and did not go out anywhere. He was very worried and sent her to inquire about her. "

“Can her beliefs not now also be my beliefs? Her feelings, her aspirations at least. "(Raskolnikov)

“But here a new story begins, the story of the gradual renewal of man, the story of his gradual rebirth, gradual transition from one world to another, acquaintance with a new, hitherto completely unknown reality. This could be the theme of a new story, but our current story is over.”

". Raskolnikov goes to hard labor. There, after many years of testing, he will probably be renewed and become fully human, that is, a warm, living human soul. "(N. N. Strakhov)

source

Answer

Raskolnikov understands that Sonya’s beliefs, feelings and aspirations should also be his beliefs. This revolution in Raskolnikov’s soul can be regarded as the first step towards repentance:

“Can her beliefs not now also be my beliefs? Her feelings, her aspirations at least. "(Raskolnikov)

Dostoevsky himself ends the novel with a phrase about “the gradual renewal and rebirth of man.” Apparently, in this way the writer gives readers hope that Raskolnikov will eventually repent of his crime:

The well-known critic N. N. Strakhov suggests that Raskolnikov will eventually repent, “renew himself and become fully human”:

". Raskolnikov goes to hard labor. There, after many years of testing, he will probably be renewed and become fully human, that is, a warm, living human soul. "(N. N. Strakhov)

These are possible answers to the question: does Raskolnikov repent of his crime?

source

essay when did Raskolnikov repent of his crime?

At the end of the novel, the hero’s renewal is just beginning: “Under his pillow lay the Gospel. He took it mechanically. This book belonged to her, it was the same one from which she read to him about the resurrection of Lazarus.

At the beginning of hard labor, he thought that she would torture him with religion, talk about the Gospel and force books on him. But, to his greatest surprise, she never spoke about it, never even offered him the Gospel.

He himself asked her for it shortly before his illness, and she silently brought him the book. Until now he has not revealed it...

But here a new story begins, the story of the gradual renewal of man, the story of his gradual rebirth, gradual transition from one world to another, acquaintance with a new, hitherto completely unknown reality. This could be the theme of a new story, but our current story is over.”

Internally, Raskolnikov still did not condemn himself. He repented, but did not repent.

Neither his own conscience, nor Sonechka’s Christian arguments, nor the idea of suffering that he suddenly understood - none of these arguments, it turns out, became either unforeseen or decisive for Raskolnikov; not one of them went beyond the scope of those arguments that would not have been provided for in advance by his sophisticated, “razor-like” consciousness.

Raskolnikov suffers not because he killed, but because he cannot live after this murder. He does not repent, but frantically searches for ways that would help him regain his lost mental balance.

And if someone else, for example, Svidrigailov, could convincingly prove that his salvation lay in a new murder, Raskolnikov most likely would have committed that too - his mental anguish is too unbearable.

By the way, one day he goes to Svidrigailov, and goes precisely for “instructions”, for a “way out”; another thing is that Svidrigailov, like Sonya, cannot offer anything that would ease his torment. In the end, having exhausted all his strength in the fight against the hated, but still mysterious “sensation,” Raskolnikov submits to Sonya’s demands, but never experiences a cleansing catharsis. And the hard labor only confirms his joyless confidence that confessing to murder will not change anything in his state of mind and will not bring him any relief.

source

Author: F. M. Dostoevsky
Work: Crime and Punishment
This essay has been copied 119,668 times

The novel by F. M. Dostoevsky is called “Crime and Punishment.” Indeed, it contains a crime - the murder of an old pawnbroker, and a punishment - trial and hard labor. However, for Dostoevsky, the main thing was the philosophical, moral trial of Raskolnikov and his inhuman theory. Raskolnikov's recognition is not completely connected with the debunking of the very idea of the possibility of violence in the name of the good of humanity. Repentance comes to the hero only after his communication with Sonya. But what then makes Raskolnikov go to the police station and confess to what he did? What reasons prompted him to do this?

Raskolnikov makes his final confession only at the very end of the novel, in the sixth part of the novel, and after this confession the description of his life in hard labor and complete repentance for what he has done begins. Sonya pushes him to confession itself, who convinces him that it will be better for him, since then he will feel relief and his soul will not suffer so much. But with what feelings does a schismatic come to confess?

He does not want to come to terms with the fact that according to human laws he committed a crime and is guilty. He continues to rebel until the very last moment, constantly thinking about whether it is worth making a confession at all, because no one can guess that it was he who committed the murder. Several times Raskolnikov tries to turn back and not go to the police station.

Before going to the police, Raskolnikov visits Sonechka again. At the moment of the meeting, he still tempts the heroine and tries to awaken in her a feeling of individualistic rebellion. He grins, his tone seems strange to Sonya. From Sonya he goes to the square to, as she advised him, bow to the people, kiss the Russian soil and publicly repent of what he has done. The thought that “these stupid, brutal hari” will surround him and watch his repentance infuriates Raskolnikov. He still hates people, the crowd in which he has to walk. He still feels that he is much higher than them, he still wants to feel like a “superman”, and these people cannot understand him and his motives.

Ultimately, he does kneel down and kiss the ground. But he does this only because he was crushed by the hopeless melancholy and anxiety of all this time and especially the last hours. He wanted to experience something new, some feeling that was sharply different from what had recently possessed him. “He rushed into the possibility of this whole, new, complete sensation. It suddenly came upon him like a fit: it ignited in his soul with one spark and suddenly, like fire, it engulfed him all. Everything in him softened at once, and tears flowed. As he stood, he fell to the ground..."

But he did not have the courage to confess to people about the crime. The words of confession stuck on his tongue as he heard the crowd talking about himself, about how he might just be drunk. Hatred for people does not allow Raskolnikov to fully open up to them, confess and, perhaps, receive forgiveness from them. After all, to confess to the “trembling creatures” means that he is a creature like them. But Raskolnikov cannot accomplish this yet.

He goes to the station. But even there, words of recognition do not immediately escape his lips. He is still unsure whether to make a confession. Several times he tries to leave the station, but some little things always delay him. He meets investigator Porokh, who has no idea about the reasons for his arrival and talks to him about all sorts of little things. Raskolnikov answers abruptly and reluctantly, his thoughts are occupied with completely different concerns. He wants to confess, but at the same time something is constantly slowing him down.

The last straw that forced Raskolnikov to confess was the news of Svidrigailov’s suicide. He could not have imagined that this man would be able to decide to do such an act. “Raskolnikov felt as if something had fallen on him and crushed him.” He thought that Svidrigailov was not tormented by his conscience, that he did not repent at all of the atrocities that he had committed in his life. And then suddenly suicide. This news struck Raskolnikov so much that he hastily left the station, and perhaps would not have returned there, but also decided to take a desperate step, if he had not met Sonya on the street, on whose face something sick and exhausted was imprinted. Remembering all the words that Sonya told him, Raskolnikov returned to the station and confessed to the crime.

But only in hard labor, after communicating with Sonya and reading the Gospel, Raskolnikov comes to real repentance. Only after this does he feel unity with the whole world and with all people.

Check out these essays

The image of Sonya Marmeladova in the novel “Crime and Punishment” Sonya Marmeladova is the heroine of Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment”. Poverty and an extremely hopeless family situation force this young girl to earn money from the panel. The reader first learns about Sonya from the story addressed to Raskolnikov by the former titular adviser Marmeladov, her father. Alcoholic Semyon Zakharovich Marmeladov vegetates with his wife Katerina Ivanovna and three small children - his wife and children are starving, Marmeladov drinks. Sonya, his daughter from his first marriage, lives on […]
Rodion Raskolnikov and Sonya Marmeladova in the novel “Crime and Punishment” Impoverished and degraded student Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov is the central character of Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky’s epoch-making novel “Crime and Punishment.” The author needs the image of Sonya Marmeladova to create a moral counterbalance to Raskolnikov’s theory. Young heroes are in a critical life situation when they need to make a decision on how to live further. From the very beginning of the story, Raskolnikov behaves strangely: he is suspicious and anxious. In the sinister plan of Rodion Romanovich, the reader […]
The moral ideal in Dostoevsky’s work “Crime and Punishment” “Beauty will save the world,” wrote F. M. Dostoevsky in his novel “The Idiot.” Dostoevsky searched for this beauty, which is capable of saving and transforming the world, throughout his entire creative life, therefore, in almost every of his novels there is a hero in whom at least a piece of this beauty is contained. Moreover, the writer did not mean the external beauty of a person, but his moral qualities, which turn him into a truly wonderful person, who with his kindness and philanthropy is able to bring a piece of light […]
Raskolnikov's theory and its refutation in Dostoevsky's novel Crime and Punishment Former student Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov is the main character of Crime and Punishment, one of the most famous novels by Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky. The name of this character tells the reader a lot: Rodion Romanovich is a man with a split consciousness. He invents his own theory of dividing people into two “categories” - “higher” and “trembling creatures”. Raskolnikov describes this theory in the newspaper article “On Crime.” According to the article, “superiors” are given the right to transgress moral laws and in the name of […]
Contradictions of Raskolnikov's theory (essay) The hero of F. M. Dostoevsky's novel “Crime and Punishment” is a poor student Rodion Raskolnikov, forced to make ends meet and therefore hates the powerful because they trample on weak people and humiliate their dignity. Raskolnikov is very sensitive to the grief of others, tries to somehow help the poor, but at the same time understands that he is not in his power to change anything. In his suffering and exhausted brain, a theory arises according to which all people are divided into “ordinary” and “extraordinary”. […]
The image of the “eternal Sonechka” in Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment” In the novel “Crime and Punishment” F. M. Dostoevsky showed the tragedy of an individual who sees many contradictions of his era and, having become completely confused in life, creates a theory that goes against the main human laws. Raskolnikov's idea that there are people - “trembling creatures” and “having the right”, finds many refutations in the novel. And, perhaps, the most striking revelation of this idea is the image of Sonechka Marmeladova. It was this heroine who was destined to share the depth of all mental anguish [...]
The theme of the “little man” in Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment” The theme of the “little man” is one of the central themes in Russian literature. Pushkin (“The Bronze Horseman”), Tolstoy, and Chekhov touched on it in their works. Continuing the traditions of Russian literature, especially Gogol, Dostoevsky writes with pain and love about the “little man” living in a cold and cruel world. The writer himself noted: “We all came out of Gogol’s “The Overcoat.” The theme of the “little man”, “humiliated and insulted” was especially strong in Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment”. One […]
The theme of the fall and spiritual rebirth of man in Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment” The human soul, its suffering and torment, pangs of conscience, moral decline, and the spiritual rebirth of man have always interested F. M. Dostoevsky. In his works there are many characters endowed with a truly reverent and sensitive heart, people who are kind by nature, but for one reason or another find themselves at the moral bottom, have lost respect for themselves as individuals, or have lowered their soul morally. Some of these heroes never rise to the same level, but become real […]
Reasons for Raskolnikov’s crime At the center of F. M. Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment” is the character of the hero of the 60s. XIX century, commoner, poor student Rodion Raskolnikov. Raskolnikov commits a crime: he kills the old money-lender and her sister, the harmless, simple-minded Lizaveta. Murder is a terrible crime, but the reader does not perceive Raskolnikov as a negative hero; he appears as a tragic hero. Dostoevsky endowed his hero with beautiful features: Raskolnikov was “remarkably good-looking, […]
The image of Rodion Raskolnikov in the novel “Crime and Punishment” In the world famous novel “Crime and Punishment” by Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky, the image of Rodion Raskolnikov is central. The reader perceives what is happening precisely from the point of view of this character - an impoverished and degraded student. Already in the first pages of the book, Rodion Romanovich behaves strangely: he is suspicious and anxious. He perceives small, completely insignificant, seemingly incidents very painfully. For example, on the street he is frightened by attention to his hat - and Raskolnikov is here […]
The meaning of the image of Sonya Marmeladova in the novel “Crime and Punishment” Sonya Marmeladova for Dostoevsky is the same as Tatyana Larina for Pushkin. We see the author's love for his heroine everywhere. We see how he admires her, speaks to God and in some cases even protects her from misfortune, no matter how strange it sounds. Sonya is a symbol, a divine ideal, a sacrifice in the name of saving humanity. She is like a guiding thread, like a moral example, despite her occupation. Sonya Marmeladova is the antagonist of Raskolnikov. And if we divide the heroes into positive and negative, then Raskolnikov will be [...]
Comparative characteristics of “Raskolnikov and Luzhin” (table) Raskolnikov Luzhin Age 23 years old About 45 years old Occupation Former student, dropped out due to inability to pay Successful lawyer, court advisor. Appearance Very handsome, dark brown hair, dark eyes, slender and thin, above average height. He dressed extremely poorly, the author points out that another person would even be ashamed to go out into the street dressed like that. Not young, dignified and prim. There is a constant expression of grumpiness on his face. Dark sideburns, curled hair. The face is fresh and [...]
Three fights between Raskolnikov and Porfiry Petrovich Porfiry Petrovich is a bailiff of investigative cases, a distant relative of Razumikhin. This is a smart, cunning, insightful, ironic, extraordinary person. Raskolnikov’s three meetings with the investigator are a kind of psychological duel. Porfiry Petrovich has no evidence against Raskolnikov, but he is convinced that he is a criminal, and he sees his task as an investigator either in finding evidence or in his confession. This is how Porfiry Petrovich describes his communication with the criminal: “Did you see the butterfly in front of the candle? Well, he's all [...]
Raskolnikov's doubles and their role in the novel "Crime and Punishment" Dostoevsky's novel "Crime and Punishment" can be read and reread several times and always find something new in it. Reading it for the first time, we follow the development of the plot and ask questions about the correctness of Raskolnikov’s theory, about Saint Sonechka Marmeladova and about the “cunning” of Porfiry Petrovich. However, if we open the novel a second time, other questions arise. For example, why the author introduces certain characters and not others into the narrative, and what role they play in this whole story. This role is for the first time [...]
The beauty of human action “Crime and Punishment” F. M. Dostoevsky was a true humanist writer. Pain for man and humanity, compassion for violated human dignity, the desire to help people are constantly present on the pages of his novel. The heroes of Dostoevsky's novels are people who want to find a way out of the impasse in life in which they find themselves for various reasons. They are forced to live in a cruel world that enslaves their minds and hearts, forcing them to act and act in ways that people would not like, or would not act in other […]
Raskolnikov's spiritual quest. The origins of the rebellion. In the center of F. M. Dostoevsky’s novel “Crime and Punishment” is the character of the hero of the sixties of the nineteenth century, commoner, poor student Rodion Raskolnikov. Raskolnikov commits a crime: he kills an old pawnbroker and her sister, the harmless, simple-minded Lizaveta . The crime is terrible, but I, like probably other readers, do not perceive Raskolnikov as a negative hero; He seems like a tragic hero to me. What is Raskolnikov's tragedy? Dostoevsky endowed his hero with beautiful [...]
“Little People” in the novel “Crime and Punishment”, the problem of social injustice and the humanism of the writer The theme of the “little man” was continued in the social, psychological, philosophical novel-reasoning by F. M. Dostoevsky “Crime and Punishment” (1866). In this novel, the theme of the “little man” sounded much louder. The scene is “yellow Petersburg”, with its “yellow wallpaper”, “bile”, noisy dirty streets, slums and cramped courtyards. Such is the world of poverty, unbearable suffering, a world in which sick ideas are born in people (Raskolnikov’s theory). Such pictures appear one after another [...]
The concept and history of the creation of the novel “Crime and Punishment” The origins of the novel go back to the time of hard labor by F.M. Dostoevsky. On October 9, 1859, he wrote to his brother from Tver: “In December I will start a novel... Don’t you remember, I told you about one confessional novel that I wanted to write after everyone else, saying that I still had to go through it myself. The other day I completely decided to write it immediately. My whole heart and blood will pour into this novel. I conceived it in penal servitude, lying on a bunk, in a difficult moment of sadness and self-destruction...” Initially, Dostoevsky planned to write “Crime and Punishment” in [...]
Epilogue and its role in the novel “Crime and Punishment” One of the strongest moments of the novel “Crime and Punishment” is its epilogue. Although, it would seem, the climax of the novel has long passed, and the events of the visible “physical” plane have already occurred (a terrible crime was conceived and committed, a confession was made, a punishment was carried out), in fact, only in the epilogue does the novel reach its true, spiritual peak. After all, as it turns out, having made a confession, Raskolnikov did not repent. “This is one thing he admitted his crime: only that he could not bear [...]
Am I a trembling creature or do I have the right? (Essay) We all look at Napoleons, There are millions of two-legged creatures. For us there is only one weapon... A.S. Pushkin Every century in the history of mankind is associated with some person who expressed his time with the greatest completeness. Such a person, such a person is called great, genius and similar words. The century of bourgeois revolutions has long been associated in the minds of readers with the phenomenon of Napoleon - a small Corsican with a lock of hair falling on his forehead. He began by participating in the great revolution, which revealed his talents and […]